The Delhi High Court has issued notice on LiveLaw’s challenge to Rule 4(4) of the IT Rules, 2021. The rule requires large social media platforms to use automated tools to identify and restrict content identical to information that platforms have already blocked.
LiveLaw says Meta restricted its Instagram reels on Supreme Court proceedings within about 15 minutes of posting. It says it got no blocking order, notice or reasons. LiveLaw reported the November 19 hearing on its own case.
“…the impugned Rule, in the form in which it has been implemented, authorises a prior restraint upon publication. The First Reel and the Second Reel were rendered inaccessible within fifteen minutes of their publication, before any human being could have examined a ‘legal request’, let alone conducted the ‘legal and human rights assessment’ which Respondent No. 3 claims to have made,” the petition said, referring to Meta.
A bench of Acting Chief Justice Nitin Wasudeo Sambre and Justice Sanjay Sharma gave the Centre and Meta four weeks to respond. The court will next hear the case on January 18, 2027.
What is LiveLaw challenging?
- Strike down Rule 4(4): LiveLaw argues that the rule exceeds the powers granted under the IT Act. They say it also violates the rights to equality, free speech, trade and life under the Constitution.
- Quash two advisories: LiveLaw challenges the advisories issued by the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) on October 8 and 10. They say the advisories have no legal basis, and allege that the restrictions on LiveLaw’s reels relied on them.
- Restore the reels: Two reels remain inaccessible in India.
- Disclose the requests: They want the Centre and Meta to disclose the legal requests and communications behind the restrictions.
- Protect news reports: They seek a declaration that platforms can’t use automated blocking against news reports without a court order. Alternatively, LiveLaw seeks a requirement that platforms provide a reasoned intimation under Rule 3(1)(d).
LiveLaw doesn’t object to platforms using technology against material depicting rape or child sexual abuse, the petition says. Its challenge covers automated blocking of content “allegedly identical” to blocked information. It is especially concerned with how platforms apply this to reports of court proceedings and news.
Which reels did Instagram restrict?
According to the petition, Instagram restricted three reels on LiveLaw’s verified account, which has over 10 lakh followers:
- October 27: A reel on the Election Commission’s affidavit in the Supreme Court on the special intensive revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. Instagram restricted it within 15 minutes and restored it that night.
- October 29: A reel on the challenges to the SIR pending in the Supreme Court. Instagram restricted it within about 15 minutes, and it remains inaccessible in India.
- October 30: A reel on Supreme Court proceedings over the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Amendment Act, 2026. The October 30 reel also remains inaccessible in India.
According to the petition, Meta told LiveLaw that it had reviewed the content and restricted it because it “went against local law. Meta’s grievance officer didn’t substantively reply to LiveLaw’s complaints. Neither Meta nor the Centre answered its legal notices of October 30.
What happened in court?
Advocate Apar Gupta, appearing for LiveLaw, told the court that Instagram took down another reel on November 18. That reel reported the Delhi Police’s affidavit in the Supreme Court, which argued that reel makers can’t claim the protection the Court gave journalists.
“I am under risk of entire account being suspended. The takedown happened last night is of reporting of Supreme Court, Delhi Police affidavit. I am not pressing for interim relief today but a shorter date,” Gupta said.
Additional Solicitor General Chetan Sharma, for the Centre, said the government could treat the petition as a representation. He said it would pass a reasoned order after hearing LiveLaw. LiveLaw’s counsel said that would be “a mere formality.” The court also noted that similar matters were listed for February 9, 2027.
What does Rule 4(4) require?
Rule 4(4) originally asked significant social media intermediaries only to “endeavour” to deploy automated tools. The February 2026 amendment to the IT Rules moved away from that wording. LiveLaw says the rule now requires platforms to proactively identify and restrict information “exactly identical” to content they have already disabled.
The petition argues this lets platforms decide the legality of content themselves. It says they do so without the safeguards that govern blocking under Section 69A of the IT Act. That, it argues, runs against the Supreme Court’s judgment in Shreya Singhal v. Union of India, which upheld Section 69A because of those safeguards.
What preceded this?
During the protests against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar in October, platforms restricted hundreds of posts in India, including LiveLaw’s reels. SFLC.in recorded about 268 content restrictions and 83 account restrictions across Meta, X, YouTube and Reddit in the first 29 days of October. Instagram accounted for 174 of the content restrictions.
Meta’s notices to users cited a “legal request,” Section 79(3)(b) of the IT Act, the IT Rules or “an automated system.” None of them named the order or the authority behind it.
MeitY’s October 8 advisory asked platforms to apply “enhanced diligence” to content that could affect public order. It also asked them to prioritise complaints from government agencies. In an October 10 advisory sent exclusively to Meta, MeitY asked the company to prevent its recommendation systems from exposing users to “a single or limited set of narratives.”
Why it matters
- Speed: If the petition’s account is accurate, Instagram blocked the reels before anyone could review them. Most of their audience hadn’t yet seen them, and restoring a news report days later doesn’t undo that.
- No order to challenge: LiveLaw still doesn’t know which authority asked for the blocks or under what law. Without that, a publisher can’t contest the restriction on its merits.
- The legality of Rule 4(4) is under challenge: The Centre’s offer of a reasoned order would deal only with LiveLaw’s reels. The court will decide whether the 2026 amendment’s automated blocking duty can apply to news reporting at all.
Also Read:
- Platforms using algorithms may lose Section 79 safe harbour
- 37 Journalists Detained, 200+ Takedown Orders During CJP Protests
The post Delhi HC issues notice on LiveLaw’s challenge to automated content blocking under IT Rules appeared first on MEDIANAMA.





