A UPI PIN does not, by itself, prove that a customer authorised a transaction, the Telangana State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (TSCDRC) has held. It ordered the State Bank of India (SBI) to refund Rs 55,000 that a woman lost in a UPI fraud, and pay her Rs 30,000 more, The420 reported.

Banks must produce concrete evidence that the account holder actually consented to a transfer, the commission said. A bench of Commission President Mamidi Christopher and members S Sandhya Rani and K Venkateswarlu passed the order on November 10.

Why did the commission reject SBI’s defence?

  • The PIN argument: SBI said the payment went through with her UPI PIN and mobile and SIM-binding checks, so she must have authorised it or exposed her credentials. The commission held that authentication alone doesn’t prove consent. It found no evidence that she made the transaction or shared her details.
  • The delay argument: SBI said she didn’t report the fraud promptly. The commission excluded Sunday from the count and held that she complained within the three-working-day window.

Because SBI didn’t refund her despite a timely complaint, the commission held it guilty of deficiency in service. It added that banks must address customer grievances properly and comply with prescribed security standards when providing banking services.

What must SBI pay?

  • Rs 55,000 as a refund of the amount lost.
  • Rs 20,000 as compensation.
  • Rs 10,000 towards litigation costs.

How did the fraud unfold?

  • November 3, 2022: Rs 55,000 was debited from the 44-year-old woman’s SBI account through UPI. She said she didn’t make the payment, authorise anyone to, or share her credentials.
  • November 6 and 7, 2022: She reported the fraud on the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal, and then in writing at her SBI branch. SBI acknowledged the complaint but didn’t refund her.
  • December 31, 2024: Police registered a First Information Report (FIR). She then took the case to the consumer commission.
  • November 10, 2026: The commission ruled in her favour, four years after the fraud.

What do RBI’s rules say?

Under the Reserve Bank of India’s (RBI) 2017 rules, a customer bears no loss from a third-party fraud if she reports it within three working days. The bank must prove that the customer was negligent.

RBI has revised these rules for transactions from January 1, 2027:

  • Longer reporting window: Customers will get five calendar days to report a third-party fraud.
  • Compensation for small frauds: Victims who lose up to Rs 50,000, even through their own negligence, can get 85% of the loss or Rs 25,000, whichever is lower, once in their lifetime.

What does the ruling mean?

The ruling holds SBI to the burden RBI’s rules already place on banks. SBI’s defence rested on the fact that her PIN and phone were used, and the commission held that this alone doesn’t prove she authorised the payment. The bank had to show she was negligent, and it didn’t.

Other forums have taken a harder line on customers. In June, the Delhi High Court held that a customer’s denial of sharing an OTP “cannot automatically fasten liability on a bank.” In that case, it treated clicking a suspicious link as negligence.

The Supreme Court, meanwhile, wants banks to carry more of the loss. In October, it said RBI’s rules must require banks to compensate digital arrest and cyber fraud victims, at least the amount they lost, when the bank’s lack of due diligence enabled the fraud.

Also Read:

The post UPI PIN doesn’t prove a customer authorised a transaction: Telangana consumer commission appeared first on MEDIANAMA.